Turtle Bay Condos for Sale – Siesta Key

Turtle Cove

Turtle Bay is a cozy condominium neighborhood consisting of two six-story mid-rise buildings constructed in 1980. It enriches the stock of Siesta Key condos for sale with its total of 82 bayfront units.

This small complex is located at 8701 Midnight Pass Road, occupying an eastern block of this major roadway in the island. The property was so developed to maximize its proximity to Little Sarasota Bay towards east. Its two buildings were designed accordion-like with glass walls, sliding doors and large windows facing the bay to allow marvelous water views within all of the condo units.

As impressive for prospective buyers of Turtle Bay condos for sale, the southern location of this condominium complex is one of the most laid back and quiet spots in Siesta Key. The condo buildings, moreover, are well set back from the street.

Curb Appeal and More

Turtle Cove

Lush and well-maintained landscaping also buffers the entire Turtle Bay complex, providing superior curb appeal and enhancing the condominium’s refreshing environment. Brick-paved paths and driveways within the grounds of Turtle Bay further sharpen its charm amongst searchers of Siesta Key condos for sale.

The amenities available to the condominium residents are as appealing. Turtle Bay’s facilities include a heated pool and spa, tennis courts, barbecue and picnic areas, boat docks, and a fishing pier. The condo owners also enjoy deeded beach access to Turtle beach across Midnight Pass Road.

Abundant Island Delights

Turtle Cove

These full trimmings of an island resort are complemented by the various points of interest near Turtle Bay. The Turtle Beach Park, one local tourist draw along Midnight Pass Road, is only about 500 meters south of the condominium. Besides beach access for swimming, this park also offers fishing and boating via the well-protected and preserved Blind Pass Lagoon.

The park’s facilities, in addition to its boat ramp and canoe/kayak launch, include a volleyball court, horseshoe pit, and playground. It also provides park benches, classroom, picnic pavilions and shelters, grills, outdoor showers, restrooms and parking.

This south Siesta Key area is likewise home to the Turtle Beach Campground and the local marina. Two seafood restaurants—Turtle Beach Grill and Turtles—are also here to add further delight to visits to this popular island destination. A free Siesta Key trolley service successfully launched in January 2017 further expands life and leisure choices of Turtle Bay residents to the northern part of the island.

Investors’ Vigil

Turtle Cove

Given its superb features and touristy location, Turtle Bay is also marketed as a rental property, with its units leasable at a three-month minimum. A close watch of Siesta Key condos for sale may be needed though for rental property investors to bag a sales-listed unit in this condominium. Its units are rarely available on the market and could also sell quickly as was the case for a Turtle Bay unit sold in March 2016 after just three days of its listing.

Market activity in Turtle Bay typically involves condos with floor plans of between 1,350 and 2,050 square feet designed with two to three bedrooms. The asking prices of these unit can start from the high $400s and level up to the million-dollar mark for spacious units which have had major upgrades.

Turtle Bay Siesta Key Condos for Sale

Below are all of the current real estate listings available for sale at Turtle Bay.

Please contact me if you would like to schedule a tour of any of the listed properties.


$849,000 - 3 BD/3 BA


Sqft: 1,972



$575,000 - 2 BD/2 BA


Sqft: 1,357


Listing data source: MFRMLS - IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.